We show here that the dephasing between the ionizing laser pulse and the proton bunch is small when compared to the plasma wavelength.
In the AWAKE experiment a short (100fs) and intense (1014W/cm2) laser pulse created the plasma by field ionization of a rubidium vapor.
The laser pulse also seeds the self-modulation instability (SMI) and set the zero of the wakefields phase.
The SMI creates a periodic modulation of the proton bunch that eventually propagates at the speed of the proton bunch.
The protons have a (initial) kinetic energy of E0=400GeV, which means that their velocity and that of the bunch is vb=(1-1/γ2)1/2c, where γ=E0/mpc2, mp the proton mass.
The laser pulse propagates at the group velocity of the laser pulse central (angular) frequency ω0 in the plasma with plasma electron frequency ωpe: vl=vg=(1-ωpe2/ω02)1/2c.
The plasma (angular) electron frequency is given by ωpe=(nee2/ε0me)1/2, where ne is the plasma density.
The proton bunch takes a time tp to travel a plasma length L given by tp=L/vb.
During that time, the laser pulse travels a length L+ΔL given by L+ΔL=vltp=vl/vbL.
Therefore the two dephase by ΔLdephase=(L+ΔL)-L=(vl/vb-1)L.
The relative dephasing can be written as:
ΔLdephase/L=(1-ωpe2⁄ω02)1⁄2/(1-1⁄γ2)1⁄2-1.
This expression can be evaluated with AWAKE parameters.
Since the bunch γ factor is large one can Taylor expand (1-1/γ2)1/2≈(1-1/2γ2) (when 1/γ2<<1).
Similarly, when the laser frequency is much larger than the plasma frequency (ω02>>ωpe2): (1-ωpe2/ω02)1/2≈(1-ωpe2/2ω02).
Therefore and further:
ΔLdephase/L≈(1-ωpe2/2ω02)/(1-1/2γ2)-1≈(1-ωpe2/2ω02)(1+1/2γ2)-1
and
ΔLdephase/L≈(1-ωpe2/2ω02)(1+1/2γ2)-1≈1+1/2γ2-ωpe2/2ω02-1.
Thus:
ΔLdephase/L≈1/2γ2-ωpe2/2ω02.
One can define the critical electron plasma density such that (ncrite2/ε0me)1/2=ω0, i.e. for which the plasma frequency is equal to the laser frequency.
With this definition:
ΔLdephase/L≈1/2γ2-ne/2ncrit.
For the AWAKE case, λ0=780nm so that ω0=2.43x1015rad/s.
At the baseline plasma density of 7x1014cm-3, ωpe=1.49x1012rad/s.
Therefore ωpe2/ω02=ne/ncrit≈3.76x10-7<<1 is well satisfied.
In addition, for γ=400, 1/γ2=6.25x106<<1.
We therefore have (at this particular plasma density) ΔLdephase/L≈2.94x10-6.
Note also that ΔLdephase is positive so that the laser pulse moves forward with respect to the proton bunch.
In the AWAKE case, the plasma length is L=10m and ΔLdephase≈2.94x10-5m.
For this dephasing to be negligible it needs to be small when compared to the plasma wavelength λpe≈1.26mm.
The condition ΔLdephase<<λpe is well satisfied (ΔLdephase/λpe≈0.023) and for practical purposes there is no dephasing.
This is true even at the lowest and highest densities envisaged, ne=1014cm-3 and 1015cm-3, respectively.
In addition, the ionization occurs within the laser pulse and we have Llaser=30μm (100fs), so that even if there was evolution of the ionization location within the laser pulse, this evolution would also have no practical effect on the wakefield phase.
We finally note that this is true for the zero of the wakefields.
The wakefields phase itself, behind the ionizing laser evolves (for example) during the growth of the SMI [A. Pukhov et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 145003 (2011)].